Thursday, 29 September 2016

Entrance Slip: Van Manen

Van Maanen's article was an interesting counter argument to the idea that we have been largely encouraged to accept, that teachers should always be reflecting. While he does not reject the idea of responding to students with tact, thoughtfulness and respect, he tries to bring to light some of the challenges in being reflective in a practical setting. According to Van Manen "In real situations the teachers must constantly and instantly act in a manner that hopefully demonstrates a thoughtful considerateness" (2). On the surface this sounds a lot like the idea of being a reflective teacher and putting careful time and consideration into each action taken. Yet he explains what at first appears to be a contradiction to this philosophy that "When you ask the same teacher how much reflective thinking really went into each of these many 'decisions' the teacher will equally readily admit that in actual fact you do not really make decisions in that sense" (11). So why is it that teachers do not make their decisions in this way? He argues it is because these decisions are made over and over again in the spur of the moment it may be difficult to find time to reflect until afterwards. This is largely due to the demanding and hectic nature of teaching. While sometimes it is certainly useful to be able to look back and recognize a mistake, this alone isn't really enough. Instead, teachers must find a way to act and behave in a way which portrays that they are thoughtful and caring at all times, what Van Manen calls teacher tact.

This concept of teacher tact was very interesting to me, because it seems to reconcile some of the challenges that reflective teaching poses. I of course want to be a reflective, caring, considerate teacher (as I'm sure most teachers do) but finding a way to balance this with meeting the demands of the classroom seems very daunting. Later in the article Van Manen describes the intricacies of this careful balance by stating "On the one hand, our actions are sedimented into habituations, routines, kinesthetic memories.... On the other hand, our actions are sensitive to the contingencies, novelties, and expectancies of our world" (20). In this sense, as teachers we should not simply aim to do one or the other, but instead incorporate both into a careful state of being where we do not rely on refelction, but instead on a more active practical wisdom. One that we can apply to all our actions as we do them, so that we can listen and rely on our instincts while still coming across as thoughtful and considerate.

All this begs the question, if one is not actively reflecting while acting, then how does one obtain this kind of wisdom and tact that can be adapted and applied to the classroom setting? While this does not seem to be fully answered by Van Manen's article, it seems this teacherly wisdom and tact is earned through years of experience and from having seen enough situations to have a good instinct or intuition on how to act in future situations as they arise. Being self aware and able to recognize actions that successful and actions that were not in the past may also help develop this kind of tactful understanding. Because this is earned through experience, I think teachers, students and parents alike all need to recognize that teachers are also human, and so they will necessarily make mistakes and hopefully learn from them. This is not to say that teachers are not responsible for their actions, indeed mistakes can often have a large impact on students and can be difficult for parents who are invested in their children's well being. For this reason I think teachers still need to responsible and accountable, but need to be aware that while mistakes certainly should be avoided, they should also be learned from.


1 comment:

  1. Very interesting post, Yuki! I know that teacher candidates can become weary of the constant calls to 'reflect' in teacher education programs, and I agree that this needs to be balanced by an awareness of the thousands of decisions teachers make every day, without having time to reflect beforehand. 'Phroenesis', or practical wisdom, is something that develops with exoerience (and learning from one's mistakes!), but I think it's also important for new teachers to be given the space to experiment and listen to their intuitive sense of what is right. Good peer mentorship is also very helpful!

    ReplyDelete