Van Maanen's article was an interesting counter argument to the idea that we have been largely encouraged to accept, that teachers should always be reflecting. While he does not reject the idea of responding to students with tact, thoughtfulness and respect, he tries to bring to light some of the challenges in being reflective in a practical setting. According to Van Manen "In real situations the teachers must constantly and instantly act in a manner that hopefully demonstrates a thoughtful considerateness" (2). On the surface this sounds a lot like the idea of being a reflective teacher and putting careful time and consideration into each action taken. Yet he explains what at first appears to be a contradiction to this philosophy that "When you ask the same teacher how much reflective thinking really went into each of these many 'decisions' the teacher will equally readily admit that in actual fact you do not really make decisions in that sense" (11). So why is it that teachers do not make their decisions in this way? He argues it is because these decisions are made over and over again in the spur of the moment it may be difficult to find time to reflect until afterwards. This is largely due to the demanding and hectic nature of teaching. While sometimes it is certainly useful to be able to look back and recognize a mistake, this alone isn't really enough. Instead, teachers must find a way to act and behave in a way which portrays that they are thoughtful and caring at all times, what Van Manen calls teacher tact.
This concept of teacher tact was very interesting to me, because it seems to reconcile some of the challenges that reflective teaching poses. I of course want to be a reflective, caring, considerate teacher (as I'm sure most teachers do) but finding a way to balance this with meeting the demands of the classroom seems very daunting. Later in the article Van Manen describes the intricacies of this careful balance by stating "On the one hand, our actions are sedimented into habituations, routines, kinesthetic memories.... On the other hand, our actions are sensitive to the contingencies, novelties, and expectancies of our world" (20). In this sense, as teachers we should not simply aim to do one or the other, but instead incorporate both into a careful state of being where we do not rely on refelction, but instead on a more active practical wisdom. One that we can apply to all our actions as we do them, so that we can listen and rely on our instincts while still coming across as thoughtful and considerate.
All this begs the question, if one is not actively reflecting while acting, then how does one obtain this kind of wisdom and tact that can be adapted and applied to the classroom setting? While this does not seem to be fully answered by Van Manen's article, it seems this teacherly wisdom and tact is earned through years of experience and from having seen enough situations to have a good instinct or intuition on how to act in future situations as they arise. Being self aware and able to recognize actions that successful and actions that were not in the past may also help develop this kind of tactful understanding. Because this is earned through experience, I think teachers, students and parents alike all need to recognize that teachers are also human, and so they will necessarily make mistakes and hopefully learn from them. This is not to say that teachers are not responsible for their actions, indeed mistakes can often have a large impact on students and can be difficult for parents who are invested in their children's well being. For this reason I think teachers still need to responsible and accountable, but need to be aware that while mistakes certainly should be avoided, they should also be learned from.
Thursday, 29 September 2016
Monday, 19 September 2016
Exit Slip: McCourt and Teacher Inspiration
Based on the
videos we watched, I believe teacher inquiry is essential to McCourt's teaching
style and is really apparent in his willingness to look to the students to give
the class direction and to adapt his lessons accordingly. A brilliant
example of this is when he found the excuse notes and used them as an
inspiration for a type of writing his students could engage with and be creative
with. Most teachers would have simply confiscated them and perhaps reported it
to the authorities, but instead McCourt was able to transform it into a mode of
engaging the class that appealed to students. Another example was how he was
happy to reveal himself to the class, and tell them short stories about himself
to build a connection and to help break up the lessons and keep the students
engaged. Of course this approach can be problematic if the stories start taking
over the lessons or when he told them story about how he stole money and was no
longer acting as a good role model. Never the less, this attitude of wanting
class to be interesting and wanting to connect with students on an equal
footing combined with his willingness to learn from his students is what seemed
to be the essence of teacher inquiry in McCourt's eyes.
Entrance Slip: Inquiring into Reflective Teaching
While I would say that I generally agree with the sentiments
between the Grant & Zeichner article, I felt that it was a bit of a slog to
go through and that parts of the article started to lose my interest. I think
this may be because so much of our current program and my university experience
has been regarding critical thinking, teacher inquiry and customized learning
experiences. As a result a lot of the articles attempt to persuade us to this
different or novel way of teaching feels a bit out of place, because it seems
less like we are already mainly focusing on that. Also, I think based on my
personal experience, a lot of teachers who I look up to and consider some of my
favourite teachers were ones who were inspired and creative and willing to take
chances to make things interesting, exciting and different. They were also all
very interested in what students were interested in and happy to be flexible
with assignment and project ideas. These kinds of teachers are part of what has
inspired me to want to teach in the classroom, and this creative, reflective
and flexible manner of teaching is a lot of what intrigues me about the
profession. Suffice to say I do not feel that I need to be convinced, and I did
not find the discussion of counterarguments to be particularly compelling or
engaging.
Despite how redundant or uninteresting certain parts of the
article felt to me, I did appreciate parts towards the end of the article on
how to approach our teacher education. In particular suggesting that we are
very active during our practicum and that we ask lots of questions as to what
the purpose of certain things are seems like very good advice for both during
and after my education. Additionally when the article acknowledges that
sometimes even a reflective teachers still need to make decisions and possibly
sacrifice some of the potential upsides of a more reflective approach in favor
of the immediate benefits of getting
through a lesson plan was very interesting. It reminds me that as much as I
want to be an inquiring teacher and I want to be creative and flexible, it
might not always be necessary to reinvent the wheel. Instead, I think I will
look to take a balanced approach that takes the good from what is popular and
then adds to it or tweaks it or modifies it to suit the needs of a particular
class.
Saturday, 17 September 2016
6 Controversial Statements About Mathematics Education Notes
Here are the notes I took from my group's discussion. We discussed topic 4: "Formal mathematics is just a frill".

While we did feel that focusing exclusively on proofs was probably going too far the other direction and that a healthy balance is required, we were very against the article on the whole.

While we did feel that focusing exclusively on proofs was probably going too far the other direction and that a healthy balance is required, we were very against the article on the whole.
Exit Slip: Sept 12th
There are plenty of ideas about this article that I disagree with and could go into lengths discussing, however I will focus on the assertion that bothered me the most. The idea that "you cannot learn from your mistakes" is a concept that deeply disagrees with me at some very fundamental level. The reason for this is probably because so much of what helped me learn mathematics and fall in love with the subject matter was doing exactly this while preparing for the Pythagoras math contest in grade 6. Trying to derive the formula for the volume of a cylinder (which I had not yet learned) and trying to create algorithms for problems the like of which I had never ever encountered was extremely time consuming. Many problems took me multiple hours to solve. However, the deep satisfaction of self directed learning and depth of understanding that working through these problems and finding a solution granted me was immense. In addition to this, when I wrote the actual contest I wound up placing 8th in the nation, and many of the questions drew upon material I never ever would have learned in school at the time. Had I never tried, I would have never succeeded and for this reason I think that this concept is deeply flawed.
That being said I think it is important to acknowledge that aspects of idea do have merit. There is such a thing as spending too much time on one problem when dealing with tests or deadlines. There is also such a thing as needing to know when to take a step back, give yourself a break, and the approach them problem again with a fresh mind and a fresh point of view. However, when stated as an absolute, the statement is harmful because it encourages students to not push themselves to their limits, and to not try and challenge themselves, to not learn for themselves and to not strive to be the best students that they can be.
That being said I think it is important to acknowledge that aspects of idea do have merit. There is such a thing as spending too much time on one problem when dealing with tests or deadlines. There is also such a thing as needing to know when to take a step back, give yourself a break, and the approach them problem again with a fresh mind and a fresh point of view. However, when stated as an absolute, the statement is harmful because it encourages students to not push themselves to their limits, and to not try and challenge themselves, to not learn for themselves and to not strive to be the best students that they can be.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)