While I would say that I generally agree with the sentiments
between the Grant & Zeichner article, I felt that it was a bit of a slog to
go through and that parts of the article started to lose my interest. I think
this may be because so much of our current program and my university experience
has been regarding critical thinking, teacher inquiry and customized learning
experiences. As a result a lot of the articles attempt to persuade us to this
different or novel way of teaching feels a bit out of place, because it seems
less like we are already mainly focusing on that. Also, I think based on my
personal experience, a lot of teachers who I look up to and consider some of my
favourite teachers were ones who were inspired and creative and willing to take
chances to make things interesting, exciting and different. They were also all
very interested in what students were interested in and happy to be flexible
with assignment and project ideas. These kinds of teachers are part of what has
inspired me to want to teach in the classroom, and this creative, reflective
and flexible manner of teaching is a lot of what intrigues me about the
profession. Suffice to say I do not feel that I need to be convinced, and I did
not find the discussion of counterarguments to be particularly compelling or
engaging.
Despite how redundant or uninteresting certain parts of the
article felt to me, I did appreciate parts towards the end of the article on
how to approach our teacher education. In particular suggesting that we are
very active during our practicum and that we ask lots of questions as to what
the purpose of certain things are seems like very good advice for both during
and after my education. Additionally when the article acknowledges that
sometimes even a reflective teachers still need to make decisions and possibly
sacrifice some of the potential upsides of a more reflective approach in favor
of the immediate benefits of getting
through a lesson plan was very interesting. It reminds me that as much as I
want to be an inquiring teacher and I want to be creative and flexible, it
might not always be necessary to reinvent the wheel. Instead, I think I will
look to take a balanced approach that takes the good from what is popular and
then adds to it or tweaks it or modifies it to suit the needs of a particular
class.
No comments:
Post a Comment