Sunday, 30 October 2016

Exit Slip: Mark Free Learning

I can certainly imagine a mark free learning environment and in fact I am beginning to feel that marks are a bit of a detriment to education. To explain why I first want to draw the same distinction I drew in class between marks or grades and assessment. While in our current system marks and grades are typically used as the primary form of assessment (eg. many classes have 70-90% of the course grade based on tests/assignments), it is important to realize they are not necessarily the same. As many of my classmates pointed out, in life we are constantly "tested" both literally and figuratively speaking. Employers want to feel confident in the employees they hire and we as a society want professionals in important positions to be well qualified - we do not want anybody to be able to claim they are a nurse, doctor, lawyer, accountant, teacher, psychologist, etc. Similarly, in education we want to see that students have an adequate understanding of the fundamentals - we do not want students moving onto calculus if they have not yet learned what the slope of a line is. Because of this reality, testing and assessment is necessary to ensure these individuals meet the desired standards of the program, employer or profession. However in many job interviews and many professional programs (such as our own teacher education program) it is on a pass/fail basis.

Grades on the other hand attempt to "rate" a student's performance in a subject in such a way that allows us to compare students and sort them from best to worst. Under this model in order for there to be "top" students who are deemed acceptable to carry on to future educaction there also necessarily must be students who are failing or underschieving in order to satisfy our normal distribution of marks. While there are plenty of valid problems around how accurately or inaccurately marks rate performance, I think there is actually a much larger problem with grades that often goes unnoticed.

By arranging, sorting and ranking people we are trying to maximize the potential of "good" students and simply crossing our fingers and hoping the "bad" students get by. This is problematic for both groups. It places increasing high pressure on smart and talented kids to continue to compete at increasingly high levels until they either reach some sort of peak or reach a level where they are no longer "smart" in comparison to their peers. I think this is where a lot of the stress and burnout from students comes from. We are continually asking smart and talented kids to prove themselves in increasingly difficult situations. Students who are not at the top of this system are also being poorly served. We are, in an extremely direct manner, saying that they are no good at things, cannot make meaningful contributions to a particular subject and have no expectations to be a contributing member of society. This is a shame because instead of telling so many people they aren't up to par because of their grades and that only the chosen few are the ones who will meaningfully impact our society, we could be trying to maximize the potential of each and every student. Why are we setting up a system that guarantees some people fail? Why not set up one where we try to help everyone find out how they can succeed? To me, this is the core of the issue.

At this point I think my stance on grades in school should be fairly apparent. Should we assess students learning? Absolutely, it makes no sense to turn a blind eye to performance, effort and progress and just say everyone is the same. There are some very practical reasons to ensure that students are  properly learning the material especially in subjects where the learning is sequential and builds on past knowledge. Because of this, having an effective form of assessment is key. What I object to however is using grades as the penultimate form of assessment for student learning and success. As an educator I want to help all kids learn and grow and become the best version of themselves that they can be and I think that grades in fact hinder this goal. I think it will take creativity and careful consideration in order to recreate our system to de-emphasizes grades. However I think it is worthwhile work that will deeply benefit the educational experience that students receive.


Wednesday, 26 October 2016

Entrance Slip: Inquiry Questions

1. Topic: 
Problems contain a lot of assumptions behind them regarding things such as what values are important (or not important), social assumptions/stereotypes, the idea of a singular objective truth/answer, etc. What values are embedded in the way we typically ask questions in math classes? How do we encourage students to think critically about these ideas?

2. Key Concepts:
a) We can be more conscious of how we ask questions and select ones that are more open ended and encourage students to think in a larger variety of ways when appropriate.

b) We can treat questions as more than just disposable vessels to teach math. Instead we can give some of the underlying ideas in these topics the time they deserve in critical discourse/analysis/discussion.

c) Social justice concepts are important and have a place in the math classroom, however we need to appropriately balance the time spent on these topics/applications with learning fundamentals and "hard skills" such as algebra, graphing, trig, computation, etc.


Thursday, 20 October 2016

Exit Slip: Breaking Down Stereotypes

Why is it that stereotypes are so pervasive even if they are so extreme? I believe a lot of it has to do with there is enough truth in them that people have this belief that even if they think it is exaggerated, it also seems to be "so true". Many of these perceptions are based on celebrities in the field and the stories, news articles, movies and books that we read about them. These stereotypes are then replicated again in other works, for example whenever a mathematician appears in a sitcom, cartoon or movie, more often than not they will draw on these cliches because the audience will recognize it quickly and be able to understand a lot about the character without needing to waste time explaining. However, it is also this feeling that stereotypes are so close to the truth that can make them problematic. As we discussed in class these descriptions are negative and exaggerated, but even if they are extreme they still seem to shape people's perceptions of what people who work or study a particular topic might be like. Sometimes this might inspire confidence, but in many other cases it may keep people from wanting to engage in the subject or believing that they are able to succeed it.

As an educator this is a concern because some students may not try to learn a subject because they may have the belief they are already doomed to fail. This seems to be especially true in mathematics where the idea that some people simply aren't born to be good at math is incredible widespread. If a child begins to struggle, it is not unlikely that they might hear this from a parent, relative or even a teacher. When this belief is then reinforced by the fact that many people may not look or desire to look like the mathematicians we see in cartoons, movies and TV shows it means many people will simply give up before they truly give the subject a try.

In order to break down these stereotypes, I think we need to draw attention to them, acknowledge them and challenge them. Show that while some people might fit some of these characteristics, there are so many more who do not. Introducing students to mathematicians who do not fit these stereotypes but are still achieving amazing results in the field I think is one of the best ways we can challenge them. Whether it is a short video (such as the field medalist videos we watched), a journal article or a summary of some research, I think exposing kids to a variety of different potential role models and discussing directly with the class how these individuals seem to fit the mold or not fit the mold can help raise awareness and open eyes. I know from my own experience having even just one role model I can look up to and who inspires me can be incredibly motivated, so why not give kids more exposure to potential role models whom might not fit the stereotype, but are every bit just as relevant?

Wednesday, 19 October 2016

Entrance Slip: Grades in Education

Grades have been emphasized throughtout my education so it is difficult for me to imagine school without grades. Yet, by comparing how I learn on my own to how I learn in school I believe that some insight into what grades do can be gained.

I have always done fairly well in school grade wise but I know that there have been times when I have been relatively more or less motivated. In my last two years of highschool and university, I knew that my grades would matter for my pursuit of future academic knowledge and so I put a lot of effort in to learning the material. Similarly when I wanted to transfer to UBC from Langara I was extremely motivated and would receive near perfect scores on tests. In these situations grades did indeed seem to be a good motivator and I think this is what many people believe grades do.

However, what is very interesting is that outside of these times I mentioned my motivation was extremely low. I wanted to do enough to get by and keep a half decent average, but I would intentionally put less effort into small assignments if they did not seem worth my time grade wise. Getting passing grades has always been relatively easy for me, so these interim periods when I know my grades won't be strongly considered I would tend to just default to coasting through courses. If any material was taught in class because it was interesting or useful, but not on the exams then I would never put in the effort to learn it because it simply didn't seem worth my effort. Especially in mandatory courses I had to complete for my degree, but I had little personal interest in. 

By comparison, when I have done self directed learning that is not for school I will read, research, write and solve problems because figuring things out is enjoyable or me. I also tend to retain this information since I am absorbing the points that I feel are most useful and internalizing them, and putting less focus on that which seems less important. By comparison, in studying for a test, everything's importance is determined by how in depth the examination will be on that topic. Instead of internalizing points of interest, I try to retain all the basic ideas enough to be able to answer questions. As a result sometimes a little over a year later I will have forgotten all of the material I learned in a course.

As a teacher, this indicates to me that taking away emphasis on grades and shifting it to learning would indeed be beneficial to students, as the article pointed out. I would like to find a way in the future to shift this focus in my classes so that students will feel encouraged to learn to understand, instead of to learn how to perform on examinations.

Wednesday, 12 October 2016

Entrance Slip: Inquiry Ideas

The following are a list of possible inquiry topics that I am considering:

1) How to incorporate "social reform" into the math class room? - I think there are many probelms worth drawing attention to so students can think critically about them such as aboriginal rights, racism, gender inequalies and accepting gender diverse individuals into society, to name a few. However, I often struggle to see how to broach these subjects in the context of a math classroom.

2) How to effectively incorporate group work into the math classroom? - In many professional fields, problems are often worked on collaboratively, however so often mathematics education boils down to studying and practicing on solitude. I am curious to investigate the possible ways of incorporating group work into the classroom to help bridge this gap. I think a lot of the challenge of this problem is that to some instructors group work just means telling students to work in a group. However, especially in math I think that more specific instruction on how to work as as a group is required for group work to be effective

3) How do we monitor technology usage in computer oriented courses? - technology is very powerful and widespread in our world today. Undoubtedly it is used in many professional work places and can be an essential classroom tool in many courses. However during school visits I noticed that computers also very often can lead to distractions for students. I'm curious how and when to incorporate technology, and how to keep students on task.

Saturday, 8 October 2016

Exit Slip: Jo Boaler

The video clip we watched in class of Jo Boaler speaking about education was very interesting to me. In particular, I was very intrigued by the clip of the classroom that was learning 'multi-dimensional mathematics'. I have had similar class structures to this where the teacher takes student input to solve a problem and it has always been quite effective.  However I think working on complex problems and giving a bit less guidance seems to be a very intriguing possibility. It lets students engage in problem solving collaboratively, and naturally raises questions such as: What information do we need? What approach is simplest given our current information? etc. Also it gives teachers a natural way to introduce new theorems, and concepts as they arise in problems so that students can see why the theory is useful. Finally, showing a work which often seems to be a mere hassle, seems natural and important when you are working collaboratively with others and require everyone to be on the same page. 

While I think it would be necessary to include some direct instruction to teach theorems and core concepts, I am definitely interested in finding opportunies to incorporate this classroom style into my own practices. I think I would also choose variations that made different kids work together and would sometimes involve smaller groups to encourage participation even from shy students.

Thursday, 6 October 2016

Entrance Slip: Garden Based Learning

After our class trip to the garden and reading the article for the week I feel like my eyes have really opened to the flexibility of garden based learning and the value that can be added by incorporating it into a wide variety of subjects.

In terms of business education I think there are a wide range of opportunities ranging from planning the budget for a garden, doing the accounting for the supplies & funds, and examining economic concepts such as supply, demand & opportunity costs. A school garden could also help provide inventory for a school store which provides opportunities for examining supply chain management, marketing and planning the school store. This also naturally introduces the students to concepts such as risk management, and taking a wide range of possible outcomes into account. I also think that by encouraging students to work in the garden they may be more in touch with the reality of what it might be like to be a worker. All too often in my undergraduate business management courses, we spent lots of time discussing how to be business managers, but almost none of the students had any real experience working on the floor of a business. This creates a disconnect that I'm sure many people can relate to personally, where the management's expectations are out of touch with the realities lived and felt by the working class.

For mathematics education the possibilities seem a bit less immediately apparent, however I do think that they exist. Various types of geometric shapes could be constructed in the garden such as the hyperboloid gate in the UBC Orchard Garden, or various decorative designs for planters such as hexagonal or octagonal planting boxes. These kind of constructive activities not only give students an opportunity to create geometric shapes, but to make precise measurements, calculate areas and create detailed drawings/plans. Fibonacci sequences appear widely in nature and flowers and could be observed in their natural state by students. Students could also practice estimation in a large variety of ways including but not limited to, the number of seeds needed to plant, the amount of soil needed and the expected yield.

While I certainly do feel that garden based learning has plenty of merits, it is not without challenges. A primary concern for schools, especially those without pre-existing gardens, is funding, however this could also be seen as an opportunity to teach students about how to fund projects by seeking grants and engaging in community fundraising. Gardens also take a fair bit of effort to maintain. As a result, either additional funds will have to be paid to automate certain processes, or student and staff time will have to be scheduled and contributed to ensure the ongoing growth and maintenance of the garden. In some cases there are relatively low cost ways of reducing the workload, for example implementing irrigation can be done on a small budget by using simple hoses or creating oyas.

Perhaps the largest concern that underlies both of the aforementioned problems and was also discussed at length in the article is that to many people, the garden may not seem essential or "worthwhile". This creates reluctance to provide adequate space, funding and staff hours to ensure the creation and maintenance of a healthy garden. This problem is also in many ways the most difficult to overcome because doing so requires challenging people's values. While there is certainly great value in convincing people to take a more naturalistic and environmentally minded mindset, it is something that will take both time as well as great effort.