Sunday, 30 October 2016

Exit Slip: Mark Free Learning

I can certainly imagine a mark free learning environment and in fact I am beginning to feel that marks are a bit of a detriment to education. To explain why I first want to draw the same distinction I drew in class between marks or grades and assessment. While in our current system marks and grades are typically used as the primary form of assessment (eg. many classes have 70-90% of the course grade based on tests/assignments), it is important to realize they are not necessarily the same. As many of my classmates pointed out, in life we are constantly "tested" both literally and figuratively speaking. Employers want to feel confident in the employees they hire and we as a society want professionals in important positions to be well qualified - we do not want anybody to be able to claim they are a nurse, doctor, lawyer, accountant, teacher, psychologist, etc. Similarly, in education we want to see that students have an adequate understanding of the fundamentals - we do not want students moving onto calculus if they have not yet learned what the slope of a line is. Because of this reality, testing and assessment is necessary to ensure these individuals meet the desired standards of the program, employer or profession. However in many job interviews and many professional programs (such as our own teacher education program) it is on a pass/fail basis.

Grades on the other hand attempt to "rate" a student's performance in a subject in such a way that allows us to compare students and sort them from best to worst. Under this model in order for there to be "top" students who are deemed acceptable to carry on to future educaction there also necessarily must be students who are failing or underschieving in order to satisfy our normal distribution of marks. While there are plenty of valid problems around how accurately or inaccurately marks rate performance, I think there is actually a much larger problem with grades that often goes unnoticed.

By arranging, sorting and ranking people we are trying to maximize the potential of "good" students and simply crossing our fingers and hoping the "bad" students get by. This is problematic for both groups. It places increasing high pressure on smart and talented kids to continue to compete at increasingly high levels until they either reach some sort of peak or reach a level where they are no longer "smart" in comparison to their peers. I think this is where a lot of the stress and burnout from students comes from. We are continually asking smart and talented kids to prove themselves in increasingly difficult situations. Students who are not at the top of this system are also being poorly served. We are, in an extremely direct manner, saying that they are no good at things, cannot make meaningful contributions to a particular subject and have no expectations to be a contributing member of society. This is a shame because instead of telling so many people they aren't up to par because of their grades and that only the chosen few are the ones who will meaningfully impact our society, we could be trying to maximize the potential of each and every student. Why are we setting up a system that guarantees some people fail? Why not set up one where we try to help everyone find out how they can succeed? To me, this is the core of the issue.

At this point I think my stance on grades in school should be fairly apparent. Should we assess students learning? Absolutely, it makes no sense to turn a blind eye to performance, effort and progress and just say everyone is the same. There are some very practical reasons to ensure that students are  properly learning the material especially in subjects where the learning is sequential and builds on past knowledge. Because of this, having an effective form of assessment is key. What I object to however is using grades as the penultimate form of assessment for student learning and success. As an educator I want to help all kids learn and grow and become the best version of themselves that they can be and I think that grades in fact hinder this goal. I think it will take creativity and careful consideration in order to recreate our system to de-emphasizes grades. However I think it is worthwhile work that will deeply benefit the educational experience that students receive.


No comments:

Post a Comment